Walk-behind lawn mowers split into four camps — battery, gas, corded electric and manual reel — and the right one depends mostly on your lawn size, terrain and tolerance for maintenance. My top pick overall is the EGO Power+ LM2134SP-2, which pairs self-propelled drive with two batteries and the strongest cutting performance in the battery category. The Honda HRX-BE stands out as the premium choice for buyers who refuse to compromise on cut quality, while the Greenworks 60V 21-inch self-propelled model offers a similar experience at a friendlier price point. The main tradeoffs you’ll face are power versus convenience: gas mowers like the YARDMAX Select PACE handle thick, wet grass on big lawns but demand oil changes and pull starts, while battery mowers start instantly and run quiet but can struggle on overgrown turf. Keep reading for the full breakdown of all 14 models and which one fits your yard.
Get garden gear delivered free — and shop member deals
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Access to Prime Big Deal Days deals on October 6–7
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Battery voltage alone doesn’t predict performance — the EGO 56V dual-battery setup and Greenworks 60V self-propelled models out-cut lower-voltage mowers because motor design and deck engineering matter more than the number on the battery.
- Self-propelled drive is the single biggest usability upgrade in this lineup; the YARDMAX CVT, Honda HRX-BE and Greenworks 60V self-propelled models save far more effort than any horsepower difference between push mowers.
- Small-deck budget mowers (15–17 inch) work well only on lawns under a quarter acre — the LawnMaster corded and MZK 40V trade cutting width for low weight and low cost, which becomes a time penalty on bigger yards.
- The American Lawn Mower 14-inch reel is the only true zero-maintenance, zero-noise option here, but it demands a mowing frequency commitment: miss a week and it can’t recover.
- The Honda HRX-BE earns its premium price through cut quality and durability rather than features — buyers who mow weekly on flat suburban lawns may get equal satisfaction from the Greenworks 60V self-propelled kit at a lower cost.
| walk-behind lawn mower | Cutting Width | Warranty |
|---|---|---|
| Greenworks 60V 21in Push Lawn | 21 in. | 4-year tool and battery |
| YARDMAX 22 in. 201cc Select PA | 22 in. | — |
| Cordless Lawn Mower | 17 in. | — |
| Honda HRX-BE 21-Inch Walk-Behi | 21 in. | 5-year residential, 90-day commercial |
| LawnMaster MEB1114K Electric C | 15 in. | — |
| PowerSmart EasyCut 18-Inch Gas | 18 inches | Two years limited |
| BILT HARD 20-Inch Gas Lawn Mow | 20 inches | — |
| Greenworks 80V 21-in Self-Prop | — | 4-year limited tool and battery |
| American Lawn Mower 14-Inch 4- | 14 inches | 90 days |
| Greenworks 60V 17" Cordless Pu | 17 inches | 4-year limited tool and battery |
| Greenworks 60V 21in Self-Prope | — | 4-year limited tool and battery |
| EGO Power+ LM2134SP-2 21" Sele | — | 5-year tool, 3-year battery |
| MZK 40V 16-Inch 2-in-1 Cordles | 16 inches | — |
| Greenworks 40V 16in Push Lawn | — | 3-year limited tool and battery |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Greenworks 60V 21in Push Lawn Mower, 5.0 Ah Battery and Charger
This model earns the top push-mower slot because it delivers gas-comparable cutting power without the fumes, fuel, or seasonal maintenance. The 60V platform with 50% more torque than 40V models translates directly into fewer stalls when you hit tall or damp patches — a real weakness of the smaller Greenworks 40V 16in Push Mower in this same lineup. The 4-in-1 discharge options (mulch, bag, side discharge, and a turbo leaf mode) mean you can handle fall cleanup without a separate tool, and the IPX4-rated steel deck holds up better to damp conditions than plastic-deck rivals. Compared with the Greenworks 60V 17-inch model, the wider 21-inch deck cuts mowing time noticeably on mid-size lawns. The main tradeoff: this is a push mower, so if your yard has slopes or you want to let the mower drive itself, the Greenworks 60V self-propelled version or the Honda HRX-BE below makes more sense.
Pros:- 60V torque output rivals a 150cc gas mower, so thick or damp grass rarely bogs the blade down
- 4-in-1 versatility including a turbo leaf mode replaces a second fall cleanup tool
- Battery and charger are cross-compatible with 75+ other Greenworks 60V tools
- IPX4 waterproofing and a rust-resistant steel deck stand up to damp grass and storage humidity
Cons:- Push-only design requires more physical effort than self-propelled alternatives on slopes
- Single 5.0 Ah battery may not finish larger lawns on one charge, and a spare is a real added expense
Best for: Suburban homeowners with flat-to-gently-rolling lawns up to about a half acre who want gas-like power in a low-maintenance push mower
Not ideal for: Buyers with hilly or sloped yards — pushing a 21-inch steel-deck mower uphill repeatedly gets tiring, and a self-propelled model would serve better
- Cutting Width:21 in.
- Power Source:60V lithium-ion battery (5.0 Ah included)
- Blade Speed:3,200 RPM
- Mowing Modes:4-in-1: mulch, bag, side discharge, turbo leaf
- Deck:Steel, IPX4 waterproof rating
- Wheels:10 in. rear, 8 in. front
- Extras:LED headlights, fast charger, grass bag
- Warranty:4-year tool and battery
Our verdict“The strongest all-around cordless push mower here for flat, mid-size lawns where gas-level cutting power and low maintenance matter most.”
YARDMAX 22 in. 201cc Select PACE 6-Speed CVT High Wheel FWD 3-in-1 Gas Self-Propelled Lawn Mower (YG2860)
For buyers who genuinely need gas — think large lawns, overgrown lots, or all-day mowing sessions without charging breaks — this YARDMAX is the strongest gas option in this roundup. The 201cc OHV engine outclasses the 144cc PowerSmart and BILT HARD gas push mowers, and the 6-speed CVT lets the mower match your walking pace instead of dragging you along at a fixed speed. That continuously variable transmission is the key differentiator: cheaper self-propelled mowers make you fight a single pace, while this one adapts whether you’re creeping around a flower bed or crossing open lawn. The automatic choke eliminates priming, which removes the most frustrating part of gas ownership for casual users. Tradeoffs are real, though: you’re signing up for fuel storage, oil changes, and winterization that battery owners never touch, and front wheel drive gives less hill traction than a rear-drive machine would.
Pros:- 201cc engine provides more sustained power than the 144cc gas push mowers in this lineup
- CVT with 6-speed selector adjusts drive speed smoothly to your pace
- Automatic choke means no-prime, one-pull-style starting
- MaxFlow volute deck and deck washout port simplify mulching and cleanup
Cons:- Gas engine demands ongoing fuel, oil, and seasonal maintenance
- Front wheel drive loses traction on slopes compared with rear wheel drive designs
Best for: Owners of large or rough lawns (half acre and up) who need unlimited runtime and self-propelled drive for long sessions
Not ideal for: Small-townhouse lawn owners or anyone who wants to avoid fuel, fumes, and engine maintenance — a cordless model like the Greenworks 60V is far less hassle
- Cutting Width:22 in.
- Engine:201cc OHV gas, automatic choke
- Drive:Self-propelled, front wheel drive
- Transmission:6-speed CVT
- Cutting Heights:7 positions, 1.38–3.55 in.
- Mowing Modes:3-in-1: mulch, bag, side discharge
- Wheels:High rear wheels, spiked rubber tires
- Assembly:Fully assembled
Our verdict“The pick for big-lawns where gas endurance and pace-matching self-propulsion beat any battery convenience argument.”
Cordless Lawn Mower, 17-Inch Walk Behind Lawn Mower for Garden
This 17-inch cordless model fills the value slot for small-lawns: it arrives with two 4.0Ah batteries and a charger included, where many budget cordless mowers ship bare and hide the true cost. At roughly 30 pounds, it’s one of the lightest walk-behinds here apart from the LawnMaster corded unit, which makes it easy to carry over steps or lift into a shed. The brushless motor holds blade speed through typical residential grass, and six height settings give enough range for a clean finish. Compared with the Greenworks 40V 16in Push Mower, the dual-battery setup and slightly wider deck give it a practical runtime and speed advantage. Where it falls short is raw muscle — this is not a mower for knee-high or wet grass, and the capped 3-inch maximum cutting height is lower than the Honda HRX-BE’s 4 inches, which limits flexibility in shoulder seasons.
Pros:- Two 4.0Ah batteries and charger included, so there’s no hidden cost to get started
- Lightweight 30 lb body is easy to push, carry, and store
- Brushless motor maintains steady blade speed on routine grass
- Simple one-button start with no pull cord or fuel to manage
Cons:- Struggles with thick, tall, or wet grass compared with 60V-class models
- Maximum 3-inch cutting height is limiting for longer seasonal grass
Best for: First-time homeowners or townhouse dwellers with small, tidy lawns who want a complete cordless package at a modest price
Not ideal for: Anyone with a quarter acre or more, overgrown grass, or a desire for one machine to handle heavy leaf cleanup — the power and runtime ceiling is too low
- Cutting Width:17 in.
- Power Source:2 × 20V 4.0Ah lithium-ion batteries
- Motor:Brushless, up to 1200W max output
- Blade Speed:3,000 RPM
- Cutting Heights:6 positions, 1–3 in.
- Runtime:Up to 40 min (~5,380 sq. ft.) per charge
- Grass Bag:50L
- Weight:30 lbs (14 kg)
Our verdict“A sensible low-cost entry into cordless mowing for small, well-kept lawns where the included dual batteries cover the whole job.”
Honda HRX-BE 21-Inch Walk-Behind Battery Powered Self-Propelled Lawn Mower (HRX217YXBEXA6)
The Honda HRX-BE sits at the top of this roundup on cut quality and refinement. Its twin-blade MicroCut system slices grass into finer pieces than single-blade rivals, which means better mulching and a bag that fills less often. The motor matches the torque of Honda’s own GCV gas engines, so unlike most battery mowers here — including the capable EGO Power+ LM2134SP — there’s no compromise in thick growth. The Versamow system lets you dial between mulching and bagging without changing attachments, a convenience none of the other picks match so elegantly, and the e-Select Drive gives precise 0–4 mph speed control rather than a single preset pace. Still, premium has a price: the 45-minute runtime caps you around a third of an acre per charge, the second battery for the dual-bay system is sold separately, and the whole package costs well above the YARDMAX or Greenworks options. This is a mower for people who keep a lawn, not just cut it.
Pros:- Twin-blade MicroCut system produces finer clippings and noticeably better mulching
- Torque output matches Honda’s gas GCV engines, so it powers through thick growth
- Versamow 4-in-1 system switches between mulch, bag, discharge, and leaf shred without attachments
- 5-year residential warranty with nationwide service support exceeds most rivals
Cons:- 45-minute runtime limits it to roughly a third of an acre per charge
- Second battery for extended runtime is a separate purchase
- Premium price is a big step up from every other cordless option here
Best for: Discerning homeowners with manicured lawns up to a third of an acre who prioritize finish quality and are willing to pay Honda money for it
Not ideal for: Budget-conscious buyers or anyone with a half-acre-plus lawn — the runtime ceiling and price make the YARDMAX gas or Greenworks 60V options more practical
- Cutting Width:21 in.
- Power Source:Battery (12 Ah lithium-ion included)
- Battery Bays:2 (second battery optional)
- Run Time:Up to 45 min (~0.37 acre) per charge
- Drive:Self-propelled, e-Select Drive 0–4 mph
- Cutting Heights:7 positions, 0.75–4 in.
- Mowing Modes:4-in-1 Versamow: mulch, bag, discharge, leaf shred
- Grass Bag Capacity:2.2 bushels
- Warranty:5-year residential, 90-day commercial
Our verdict“The choice for lawn enthusiasts who want gas-grade power and Honda-level cut quality in a battery mower — provided the budget and lawn size fit.”
LawnMaster MEB1114K Electric Corded Lawn Mower, 15-Inch, 11 Amp
Sometimes the right mower is simply the cheapest one that starts every single time, and that’s this LawnMaster’s whole argument. Corded power means zero batteries to degrade, zero gas to store, and unlimited runtime as long as you have an outlet and an extension cord — something no battery model in this roundup, not even the budget 17-inch cordless, can claim. At 28 pounds with foldable handles, it stores in a corner of a garage or shed where a YARDMAX or Honda would dominate the floor space. The honest tradeoff is scale: a 15-inch deck is the narrowest cutting path here apart from the push reel mower, so anything beyond a small urban lawn turns into a long, tedious session of overlapping passes, and the cord demands planning around landscaping. For a townhouse patch or a rental property touch-up, though, the simplicity is hard to beat.
Pros:- Unlimited runtime — just plug in and mow, with no batteries to charge or replace
- Featherweight 28 lb body with foldable handle stores almost anywhere
- Virtually no maintenance beyond blade care
- 5 cutting heights give decent flexibility for a compact mower
Cons:- 15-inch cutting path makes anything beyond a small lawn slow and tedious
- Corded design restricts range and requires managing a cord around trees and beds
Best for: Apartment dwellers, townhouse owners, or occasional trimmers with small patches of grass and access to an outdoor outlet
Not ideal for: Anyone with more than a small yard — the 15-inch deck and cord management make medium lawns a chore, and battery models are worth the upgrade
- Cutting Width:15 in.
- Power Source:Corded electric, 11 Amp
- Blade Speed:3,300 RPM
- Cutting Positions:5 (1.4–3 in.)
- Rear Wheel Size:7.75 in.
- Grass Bag:7 gallons
- Weight:28 lbs
Our verdict“The logical no-frills choice for tiny lawns where instant, endless power and compact storage outweigh cutting width.”
PowerSmart EasyCut 18-Inch Gas Walk-Behind Push Lawn Mower, 144cc 4-Cycle Engine
The PowerSmart EasyCut makes the list as the most affordable path into gas-powered cutting, and it earns that role by keeping things simple. The 144cc OHV engine with auto choke and primer starts without a fight, which matters at this price point where cheap gas engines often frustrate owners. Compared with the BILT HARD 20-Inch, the PowerSmart gives up two inches of cutting width and the convenience of single-lever height adjustment, so it will take more passes and more bending to change cutting heights. The tradeoff is a genuinely maneuverable, lightweight machine that’s easy to push around trees and garden beds.
The real limitation is discharge flexibility: side discharge only, with no mulching or bagging. If clippings on the lawn bother you, the Greenworks 60V 17-inch offers mulching and bagging instead.
Pros:- Auto choke and primer make cold starts consistently easy
- Steel deck feels sturdier than plastic alternatives at this price
- 5-position height adjustment handles varied grass conditions
- Lightweight frame is easy to push and store
Cons:- Side discharge only — no mulching or bagging capability
- 18-inch deck means more passes on anything beyond a small lawn
Best for: Budget-conscious buyers with small, flat yards who want gas power without a big investment
Not ideal for: Anyone who wants to mulch or bag clippings, or who maintains a lawn over a quarter acre — the narrow deck and side-only discharge become a chore
- Engine:144cc 4-cycle OHV
- Cutting Width:18 inches
- Cutting Height Range:1.5″ – 3.9″
- Height Positions:5
- Deck Material:Steel
- Discharge Type:Side discharge
- Wheels:8″ rear / 7″ front
- Warranty:Two years limited
Our verdict“A sensible, no-frills gas mower for small yards where the lowest upfront cost matters more than cutting-mode versatility.”
BILT HARD 20-Inch Gas Lawn Mower with 144cc 4-Cycle OHV Engine
Where the PowerSmart EasyCut offers five height positions, the BILT HARD 20-inch steps up to 8-position single-lever adjustment spanning 0.7 to 3.2 inches — that’s a wider range at the low end, which matters if you like a tight, manicured cut on warm-season grass. The no-prime auto choke starting system matches the best in this gas field, and the double ball-bearing wheels roll noticeably smoother than the plain wheels on cheaper push mowers.
The tradeoffs are real, though. There’s no grass collection bag, and unlike the Greenworks 80V self-propelled model, you’re pushing this yourself across the full 20-inch swath. The maintenance quirk — you can’t tip the mower over for cleaning — makes deck upkeep more awkward than it should be.
Pros:- 8-position single-lever height adjustment covers a wide 0.7″-3.2″ range
- Auto choke starts with no priming ritual
- Ball-bearing wheels roll smoothly over uneven ground
- Foam-wrapped angled grip reduces hand fatigue
Cons:- No grass collection bag included
- Cannot be tipped or dumped, complicating cleaning and maintenance
Best for: Homeowners who want precise, low cutting heights and smooth-rolling push mowing on mid-sized lawns
Not ideal for: Buyers who want to bag clippings or hate fussy maintenance — no bag and the no-tipping rule will grate over time
- Engine:144cc 4-cycle OHV
- Torque:5.8 ft-lb
- Cutting Width:20 inches
- Starting System:Auto choke, no primer
- Cutting Height Range:0.7″ – 3.2″
- Height Positions:8, single-lever
- Wheels:7″ rear / 6″ front, double ball-bearing
Our verdict“The gas push mower to pick when cutting-height precision matters more than bagging or self-propulsion.”
Greenworks 80V 21-in Self-Propelled Lawn Mower with 4.0 Ah Battery and Charger
This is the pick when you want to quit gas entirely without giving up power or traction. The 80V brushless motor delivers cutting authority that rivals mid-range gas machines, and the rear-wheel-drive self-propulsion with variable speed means you steer rather than push — a genuine advantage over every push mower in this lineup, including the capable Greenworks 60V 21-inch push model. Coverage of up to half an acre per charge puts it in a different class than the smaller Greenworks 60V 17-inch, which caps out around 40 minutes of mowing.
The honest caveat: that half-acre figure assumes favorable conditions. Dense, wet, or overgrown grass drains the battery faster, so a neglected lawn can cut your runtime short mid-job. Still, the four-year tool-and-battery warranty and compatibility with 75+ Greenworks 80V tools soften the ownership risk considerably.
Pros:- Cuts up to half an acre on a single 4.0 Ah charge
- Brushless motor delivers high torque quietly
- Self-propelled rear-wheel drive with variable speed
- LED headlights allow low-light mowing
Cons:- Runtime varies heavily with grass density and technique
- Single battery may not finish larger lawns without a recharge pause
Best for: Suburban homeowners with quarter- to half-acre lawns who want gas-free mowing without the physical effort of pushing
Not ideal for: Anyone mowing overgrown or dense grass regularly — battery runtime drops quickly under heavy load and there’s no quick gas refill equivalent
- Voltage:80V
- Deck Size:21 inches, steel
- Battery:4.0 Ah (included with charger)
- Motor:Brushless
- Propulsion:Self-propelled rear-wheel drive, variable speed
- LED Headlights:Yes
- Warranty:4-year limited tool and battery
- Compatibility:75+ Greenworks 80V tools
Our verdict“The strongest case for going all-battery on a mid-sized lawn, provided you keep the grass from getting away from you.”
American Lawn Mower 14-Inch 4-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower – Red
Against the motorized options throughout this roundup, the American Lawn Mower 14-inch reel plays a completely different game: no fuel, no battery, no fumes, and almost no noise. Its scissor-like cut slices grass cleanly rather than tearing it, which lawn-care enthusiasts argue is healthier for the blade — something no rotary mower here, gas or electric, can claim. At 19 pounds, it’s lighter than everything else in the lineup and hangs on a garage wall.
The constraints are just as clear. It struggles with grass over 4 inches or damp grass, so it demands a regular mowing schedule, and the 14-inch width makes it practical only for small lawns. Compared with something like the Greenworks 40V 16-inch, you trade effortless power for exercise and silence. The 90-day warranty also reflects its utilitarian build.
Pros:- Zero emissions, fuel, or noise
- 19-pound weight makes it effortless to carry and store
- Scissor-cut is gentler on grass blades than rotary tearing
- Minimal maintenance — occasional sharpening only
Cons:- Ineffective on grass taller than 4 inches or when wet
- Impractical beyond small lawns due to manual effort
- Short 90-day warranty
Best for: Owners of small, well-kept cool-season lawns who want a silent, zero-emission cut and don’t mind the workout
Not ideal for: Anyone with a lawn over roughly a quarter acre, tall or wet grass, or warm-season grasses that grow fast — it will fight you every step
- Weight:19 lbs
- Cutting Width:14 inches
- Height Adjustment:0.5″ – 1.75″
- Maximum Grass Height:4 inches
- Reel Type:4-blade, alloy steel reel and bed knife
- Wheels:8.5-inch polymer
- Warranty:90 days
Our verdict“A deliberate lifestyle choice for tiny, tidy lawns — not a shortcut to easier mowing on anything larger.”
Greenworks 60V 17″ Cordless Push Lawn Mower with 4.0Ah Battery and Charger
This mower occupies the sweet spot between the Greenworks 40V 16-inch and the larger Greenworks 60V 21-inch: more power and a longer warranty than the 40V, but lighter and cheaper-feeling to maneuver than the 21-inch push model. The 90-minute full recharge is the standout — roughly twice as fast as many competitors — so even if the 40-minute runtime runs out, you’re not parked for the afternoon. The 2-in-1 mulching and rear bagging also beats the PowerSmart’s side-discharge-only setup for lawn flexibility.
The tradeoffs come down to scale. A 17-inch deck means more laps than a 20- or 21-inch machine, and there’s no side-discharge option when the bag fills and mulching isn’t ideal. It’s a push mower too, unlike the 80V self-propelled Greenworks, so slope and lawn size should guide your choice.
Pros:- No gas, fumes, or engine maintenance
- Fast 90-minute full recharge minimizes downtime
- 2-in-1 mulching and rear bagging for clippings flexibility
- Battery works across 75+ Greenworks 60V tools
Cons:- 40-minute runtime limits larger lawns
- 17-inch deck is narrower than typical gas mowers
- No side-discharge mode
Best for: Small-yard owners already in or entering the Greenworks 60V battery ecosystem who want mulching and bagging in a light package
Not ideal for: Lawn owners beyond a quarter acre or with sloped terrain — the 17-inch push format and 40-minute ceiling make the job slow
- Voltage:60V
- Cutting Width:17 inches
- Battery:4.0Ah lithium-ion (included)
- Runtime:Up to 40 minutes
- Charge Time:90 minutes
- Height Adjustment:6 positions, 1.5″ – 3.15″
- Cutting Modes:2-in-1 mulching and rear bagging
- Motor:Brushless
- Warranty:4-year limited tool and battery
Our verdict“A smart compact electric pick for small lawns, especially if the battery doubles as power for other Greenworks tools.”
Greenworks 60V 21in Self-Propelled Lawn Mower, (2) 4.0 Ah Battery Kit
This option stands out for bridging the gap between gas convenience and cordless living on bigger properties. With two 4.0Ah batteries and a rear-wheel drive self-propel system, it handles up to 3/4 acre per charge — territory where the smaller Greenworks 40V 16in push mower simply can’t go. Compared with the EGO Power+ LM2134SP-2, it trades some raw cutting torque for a lighter feel and a 4-in-1 system that adds turbo leaf pickup, a genuinely useful fourth mode the EGO lacks. The battery platform is a quiet advantage: it shares batteries with 75+ Greenworks 60V tools, so a second battery isn’t just a mower spare. The tradeoff is that thick, wet grass drains the batteries faster than the claimed runtime, and self-propel adds weight worth considering if your storage space is tight.
Pros:- Up to 3/4 acre of cutting per dual-battery charge
- Rear-wheel drive traction handles slopes and thick grass
- 4-in-1 versatility including turbo leaf pickup
- Batteries interchangeable with 75+ Greenworks 60V tools
Cons:- Runtime drops noticeably in dense or wet grass
- Heavier and pricier than comparable push-only models
Best for: Homeowners with half-acre-plus lawns who want gas-free mowing without pushing a heavy deck themselves
Not ideal for: Buyers with small urban lawns — the 21-inch self-propelled deck is more machine than a quarter-acre lot justifies
- Deck Width:21 inches
- Voltage:60V
- Batteries Included:Two 4.0Ah
- Coverage Per Charge:Up to 3/4 acre
- Drive:Self-propelled, rear-wheel drive with variable speed
- Mowing Modes:4-in-1: mulch, bag, side discharge, turbo leaf pickup
- Motor:Brushless
- Warranty:4-year limited tool and battery
Our verdict“This pick makes the most sense for large-lawn owners who want self-propelled electric power and a battery ecosystem to build around.”
EGO Power+ LM2134SP-2 21″ Select Cut Self-Propelled Cordless Lawn Mower
If cutting power is the deciding factor, this model sits at the top of the cordless field. Its 7.0 ft-lbs of torque genuinely exceeds gas equivalents, and the Select Cut multi-blade system lets you swap blades for mulching, bagging, or extended runtime — a flexibility no single-blade competitor offers. Runtime is the other headline: up to 100 minutes on two 6.0Ah batteries, roughly a third more working time than the Greenworks 60V kit. The Touch Drive self-propel is more intuitive than lever-based systems, letting you feather speed from 0.9 to 3.1 mph with palm pressure. The honest tradeoffs: it’s expensive, it’s heavy with two large batteries mounted, and thick or wet grass can cut runtime sharply — the same weakness as every battery mower here, just from a higher starting point.
Pros:- Gas-exceeding 7.0 ft-lbs of cutting torque
- Up to 100 minutes runtime on two included 6.0Ah batteries
- Select Cut blade system tailors performance to task
- 5-year tool warranty beats most of the lineup
Cons:- Highest price tier in this roundup
- Heavy with dual batteries mounted
- Runtime falls sharply in thick or wet grass
Best for: Buyers replacing a gas mower who refuse to compromise on power and runtime and will pay for it
Not ideal for: Budget-conscious buyers or anyone with a small flat lawn — the Honda HRX-BE and simpler push models deliver comparable results for less complexity and cost
- Deck Width:21 inches
- Voltage:56V
- Cutting Torque:Up to 7.0 ft-lbs
- Runtime:Up to 100 minutes
- Batteries Included:Two 56V 6.0Ah ARC Lithium
- Self-Propelled:Yes — Touch Drive, 0.9–3.1 mph
- Cutting Heights:8 positions, 1–4 inches
- Grass Bag Capacity:2 bushels
- Warranty:5-year tool, 3-year battery
Our verdict“This is the cordless mower for people who want to forget gas entirely without giving up performance — provided the budget allows it.”
MZK 40V 16-Inch 2-in-1 Cordless Push Lawn Mower with Brushless Motor
This model earns its spot as the everything-in-the-box option for first-time electric mowers. The kit ships with two 20V batteries and a dual-port charger, so you can charge both simultaneously and rotate them for up to 45 minutes of mowing — a smarter downtime strategy than the single-battery Greenworks 40V 16in setup. The brushless motor spinning at 3400 RPM is impressive at this tier, and the 16-inch deck with 5-position height adjustment covers the basics of lawn care without clutter. Compared with the LawnMaster MEB1114K corded mower, you gain total freedom from extension cords for similar money in the battery-and-charger equation. The compromises are real, though: a 16-inch deck means more passes on any lawn over a quarter acre, the 1.4–3 inch height range tops out low for tall fescue, and 31 pounds is hefty for a machine you push yourself.
Pros:- Complete kit includes mower, two batteries, dual charger, and grass bag
- Brushless motor at 3400 RPM outperforms typical budget brushed motors
- Dual-battery rotation cuts downtime
- Compact 16-inch deck stores easily in tight sheds or garages
Cons:- 45-minute runtime and narrow deck limit it to small lawns
- 31.1 pounds is heavy for a non-self-propelled mower
Best for: First-time homeowners or renters with small flat lawns who want a complete, cordless starter kit
Not ideal for: Anyone with a half-acre lot or thick southern grass — the narrow deck and modest height ceiling make the job slow and strained
- Voltage:40V (2x 20V)
- Cutting Width:16 inches
- Motor:Brushless, up to 3400 RPM
- Runtime:Up to 45 minutes
- Batteries:2x 20V 4.0Ah lithium with dual-port charger
- Grass Bag Capacity:40L (11 gallons)
- Cutting Heights:5 positions, 1.4–3 inches
- Mowing Modes:2-in-1: mulch, rear bagging
- Weight:31.1 pounds
Our verdict“A sensible entry point for small-lawn owners who value a complete package over raw capability.”
Greenworks 40V 16in Push Lawn Mower, 4.0 Ah Battery and Charger
Simplicity is the whole point here. This mower is 35% lighter than steel-deck models, which translates directly into easier pushing, easier turning at garden edges, and easier lifting into a car trunk or onto a storage shelf. Where the Greenworks 60V 21in self-propelled machine is built for acreage, this one is built for the person with a modest townhouse lawn who values low effort over high output. The single-lever, 5-position height adjustment is faster to use than wheel-by-wheel systems on older gas mowers like the PowerSmart EasyCut, and the 40V battery platform opens the door to 75+ matching tools down the road. The tradeoffs follow from the size: a 16-inch deck means more passes, there’s no side discharge option, and the single included 4.0Ah battery caps you around 1/3 acre — less runtime headroom than the dual-battery MZK kit.
Pros:- Ultralight design, 35% lighter than steel-deck mowers
- Single-lever height adjustment across 5 positions
- Battery compatible with 75+ Greenworks 40V tools
- 3-year tool and battery warranty
Cons:- Single 4.0Ah battery limits runtime to roughly 1/3 acre
- Narrow 16-inch deck and no side discharge reduce versatility
Best for: Suburban homeowners with small, flat lawns who want a light, low-maintenance electric mower at an accessible price
Not ideal for: Larger or hilly properties — no self-propel, a narrow deck, and one battery make anything past 1/3 acre a chore
- Deck Width:16 inches
- Voltage:40V
- Battery Included:4.0Ah with charger
- Coverage Per Charge:Up to 1/3 acre
- Height Adjustment:Single lever, 5 positions
- Mowing Modes:2-in-1: mulch, rear bagging
- Deck Construction:Lightweight (35% lighter than steel)
- Warranty:3-year limited tool and battery
Our verdict“The right choice for small-lawn owners who prioritize light weight and simplicity over cutting capacity.”
How We Picked
I evaluated each mower on four buyer-facing criteria: cutting performance (deck width, blade speed, discharge/bagging/mulching flexibility, and ability to handle tall or damp grass), usability (starting mechanism, self-propelled drive, weight, and height adjustment), maintenance burden (gas oil changes and pull starts versus battery charging versus reel blade sharpening), and fit for lawn size — because a mower that excels on a quarter-acre suburban lot is the wrong tool for a two-acre property. Runtime and fuel capacity were judged relative to realistic mowing sessions, not laboratory conditions.
The ranking logic favors versatility and long-term ownership satisfaction. Mowers with self-propelled drive and 3-in-1 discharge options rank above comparable push models because they suit a wider range of buyers and terrains. Within the battery group, dual-battery kits and higher-voltage platforms rank higher since single-battery, small-deck models create runtime anxiety on medium lawns. Budget gas push mowers sit mid-pack: cheap to buy and powerful, but heavier and noisier than equivalent battery options. The reel mower and corded models fill specific niches at the bottom of the list — not because they’re bad, but because their use cases are narrower.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Walk-behind Lawn Mowers
Before settling on a specific model, it helps to understand the structural decisions that shape every walk-behind mower purchase. These factors matter more than brand loyalty or feature checklists, and getting them wrong is the most common reason buyers end up replacing a mower within two seasons.Match Power Source to Lawn Size First
The most expensive mistake in this category is buying a power source that fights your property. Corded mowers make sense only for small, rectangle-shaped lawns near an outlet — dragging 100 feet of cord around trees and garden beds gets old fast. Single-battery cordless mowers comfortably handle quarter-acre lots; beyond that, you’ll want either a dual-battery kit or a gas engine. Gas mowers remain the answer for half-acre-plus properties, dense St. Augustine or Zoysia grass, and anyone who lets the lawn grow too long between cuts. A common trap is assuming battery is always the ‘modern’ choice: if your grass is thick and your lot is large, a modest gas push mower will outperform a premium battery mower that dies halfway through the job.
Push vs. Self-Propelled: The Effort Equation
Self-propelled drive typically adds meaningful cost and some weight, but it converts a sweaty chore into a walk — and on slopes, it’s the difference between manageable and miserable. Front-wheel drive (like the YARDMAX) turns more easily around obstacles but loses traction on hills; rear-wheel drive (like the Honda and EGO) climbs better and handles bagging weight more effectively. Push mowers aren’t just a budget compromise, though: they’re lighter, simpler, and have one less system to break. If your lawn is flat and under a third of an acre, a quality push mower is often the smarter buy. Buyers over 55 or anyone with a sloped yard should treat self-propelled drive as non-negotiable rather than an upgrade.
Deck Width vs. Maneuverability
Cutting width is a time calculation, not a status symbol. A 21- or 22-inch deck finishes a medium lawn noticeably faster than a 16-inch deck, but wide decks are harder to steer through tight gates, around flower beds, and into garage storage. Measure your narrowest gate before buying — a 22-inch deck will not fit through a standard 20-inch gate gap. Narrow decks (14–17 inches) also shine on small, obstacle-dense urban lawns where a wide deck spends more time trimming edges than cutting. As a rule, lawns under a quarter acre reward maneuverability, while anything larger rewards width.
Discharge Options and Grass Conditions
3-in-1 capability (mulching, bagging, side discharge) matters more than most buyers expect. Mulching returns nutrients to the soil and saves you from emptying bags, but only when grass is dry and cut frequently — mulching tall, wet grass leaves clumps that can smother the lawn. Bagging is unavoidable in wet climates, during spring growth surges, and for anyone collecting leaves in fall. Side discharge is the fallback for overgrown lawns where bagging would need emptying every 30 feet. Cheap mowers that only mulch force you into a strict mowing schedule; models with all three modes buy you flexibility when life gets busy and the lawn gets away from you.
Battery Platform Lock-In
Once you buy one battery tool, you’re effectively joining that brand’s ecosystem — batteries are the expensive part, and they don’t cross brands. Greenworks appears four times in this roundup precisely because its 40V and 60V platforms span dozens of tools: if you already own a Greenworks trimmer or blower, buying a Greenworks mower means spare batteries and one charging system. The same logic applies to EGO’s 56V line. Before choosing a mower on specs alone, inventory any cordless outdoor tools you already own — matching the platform can effectively give you free backup batteries, while mismatching doubles your charging clutter and long-term costs.
Real Maintenance Costs Over Five Years
The sticker price is only part of the equation. Gas mowers need annual oil changes, air filters, spark plugs, fuel stabilizer over winter, and blade sharpening — figure on an hour of work each spring plus consumables. Battery mowers need almost nothing except blade sharpening, but batteries degrade and typically need replacement after three to five years, which is a real cost to budget for. Corded mowers are nearly maintenance-free but the cords themselves wear out. Reel mowers need blade adjustment and occasional sharpening, and skipping it makes them brutally hard to push. Buy based on the maintenance you’ll actually do, not the maintenance you intend to do — an unmaintained gas mower is the worst-owning category of all.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much lawn can one battery actually mow?
Realistically, expect 30 to 45 minutes of runtime from a single charged 4.0Ah-class battery under normal cutting conditions, which covers roughly a quarter acre. Runtime drops sharply when the grass is tall, thick or damp — the motor works harder and can drain a battery 30–40% faster. Dual-battery kits like the EGO LM2134SP-2 or the Greenworks 60V self-propelled kit solve this by letting you mow continuously, swapping to the second battery mid-cut. If your lawn exceeds a third of an acre and you prefer battery power, a dual-battery setup isn’t a luxury — it’s the difference between finishing the job and finishing half of it.
Are gas mowers still worth buying with battery mowers improving so much?
For large lawns, tough grass, and heavy spring growth, gas still wins on raw capability — the YARDMAX 201cc engine will power through wet, overgrown turf that stops most battery mowers dead. Gas also refuels in seconds versus an hour-plus recharge, which matters on half-acre-plus properties. The tradeoffs are real: pull starts, oil changes, winter fuel prep, noise, and emissions. My honest read is that buyers with lawns under half an acre and normal grass types get a better ownership experience from a quality 60V+ battery mower, while those with big properties, southern grass varieties, or professional-level cutting demands should stay with gas a few more years.
Can a manual reel mower really replace a powered mower?
Only under specific conditions, and being honest about them saves disappointment. The American Lawn Mower 14-inch reel works well on flat lawns under about 2,000 square feet with thin grass types like fescue or bluegrass, mowed at least weekly. Reel mowers struggle badly with tall grass — once growth exceeds roughly four inches, they push grass over instead of cutting it, requiring multiple passes. They also can’t handle twigs, which jam the blades, and they fight on bumpy or sloped terrain. If you have a small, flat, cool-season lawn and enjoy the quiet, zero-fuel routine, a reel mower is genuinely satisfying. Everyone else should treat it as a supplement, not a replacement.
Is self-propelled drive worth the extra cost over a push mower?
For most buyers with a third of an acre or more, yes — and it’s the upgrade owners regret skipping most often. Self-propelled drive costs more upfront but eliminates the pushing effort entirely; you steer while the mower drives itself, which matters most on slopes, when bagging heavy clippings, and in hot weather. Push mowers still make sense for flat, small lawns where the weight savings and lower price win, and the simplest push models have fewer components that can fail. One caveat: variable-speed drive (like the YARDMAX CVT or EGO’s select-speed) is far more comfortable than single-speed systems, because you can match the mower’s pace to your walking speed rather than shuffling behind it.
What deck size should I choose for a small yard?
For lawns under a quarter acre, a 16- to 18-inch deck usually beats a 21-inch one, contrary to what the spec sheet suggests. Small decks are lighter, easier to turn around flower beds and trees, simpler to store, and they pair naturally with affordable battery platforms like the Greenworks 40V or MZK 40V. The narrower cut costs you time on open stretches of grass, but on a small, obstacle-dense lot, a wide deck spends much of its time in awkward repositioning anyway. The one measurement that overrides everything: check your narrowest gate or storage door first. A 21- or 22-inch deck that can’t fit through your fence gate is the wrong mower at any price.
Conclusion
After comparing all 14 mowers, the right choice comes down to your lawn and your routine. For best overall, the EGO Power+ LM2134SP-2 delivers the best balance of cut quality, self-propelled convenience and battery-platform flexibility — it suits the widest range of suburban yards. The best value pick is the Greenworks 60V 17-inch push mower, which brings a quality cut and a shared battery platform to small and medium lawns at a modest price. For best premium, the Honda HRX-BE justifies its cost with exceptional cut quality and durability for buyers who keep a mower for a decade. Beginners and anyone who wants the simplest possible machine should start with the Greenworks 40V 16-inch push mower — lightweight, quiet and nearly foolproof. For specific needs: large or tough-grass properties call for the YARDMAX Select PACE gas mower, tiny eco-minded lawns suit the American Lawn Mower reel, and budget-conscious owners of small flat lawns can rely on the LawnMaster corded model. Match the mower to the yard you actually have, not the one you imagine, and any of these picks will serve you well for years.
Fall yard work Picks
leaf blowers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
